The proof is first-rate. The first screen gets in its way.
Harry Joiner has been recruiting ecommerce leaders since 2005, with hundreds of searches closed and 66 brands on the client list, from Petco and KIND Snacks to adidas and Williams-Sonoma. A first-time visitor sees little of that. On a phone they meet a headline that repeats itself, a menu they can’t open and a single phone number 2.6 screens down. None of it is hard to fix: all eight quick wins below are edits inside WordPress.
UX health score: 59 / 100
A structured review against Nielsen’s 10 usability heuristics (scored 0–4 each, half of the score), three task walkthroughs (35%) and a scan for manipulative design (15%). The site is honest and clean: no dark patterns at all. Points go on first impression, the phone and the path to starting a search.
Hundreds of searches, 66 named brands, 18 testimonials with names, titles and LinkedIn links.
Desktop LCP 1.5 s. Lighthouse SEO 100. Indexable, with a sitemap.
Repeated headline, two logos, a main button that points to a staging server.
The menu button renders off screen; the only contact is 2.6 screens down.
Phone only on the homepage. The About page’s button leaves for EcommerceJobs.com.
No analytics running, so no visits, calls or sources are counted.
Clients and press live on About; testimonials rotate in carousels.
Brand green and gold are too light for white text; phone LCP 7.6 s in the lab.
- A sharp, specific niche: contingency search, Manager to CXO, transactional multichannel ecommerce, B2C and B2B.
- Real testimonials with full names, titles, companies and LinkedIn links: easy to verify, hard to fake.
- A salary range stated up front ($75K to $250K and up, plus bonus and options), which sets expectations for both sides.
- Fast on desktop (LCP 1.5 s, 0 ms blocking time), indexable, Yoast in place, and a visible focus ring for keyboard users.
Tested, not assumed. Every number here comes from the live site on November 16, 2026, with a source in my evidence log. Each fix is a hypothesis until it’s measured. How I’d prove it.
Three moments, side by side
Red pins mark the problems on the live site. Green pins with the same numbers mark the fix in the concept. Tap any screenshot to see it full size.
2134
2134The first screen
What a hiring manager sees in the first five seconds on a phone.
- 1The headline repeats: “for B2C + B2B B2C + B2B ecommerce.”One clear promise: Manager to CXO, pay only if you hire.
- 2Two logos at once push the menu button off the screen.One logo, a call button and a menu that opens.
- 3“Learn more about us” opens a WP Engine staging address.“I’m hiring” and “I’m looking” doors, on the real site.
- 4No way to get in touch in the first screen.Tap-to-call in the first screen and a pinned “Start a search” bar.
7
77The proof
The strongest selling point is a wall of grey text on a second page.
- 766 brands, “hundreds” of searches and the press list live on About, in small grey type.A track record card in the hero and a client strip under it, linking to all 66.
- 1418 testimonials rotate every 7 seconds in two carousels.Three quotes shown in full, chosen for what employers ask.
284
248Starting a search
The step that turns a visit into a fee.
- 2A see-through sticky header lays both logos over the text as you scroll.A solid header with one logo.
- 8White on gold and white on green: 2.3:1 and 2.4:1 contrast.Deeper brand green (5.6:1) and dark text on gold (7.2:1).
- 4Phone is the only option. No email, no form, nothing after hours.A two-minute brief, with the phone right beside it.
Where each visitor’s path breaks
I walked three real tasks step by step and asked four questions at each step: will they try it, will they see how, will they understand it, and will they know it worked? One “no” is a hesitation. Two is a failure.
A VP of Ecommerce, on a phone, wants to start a search
The visit that pays the bills. It ends with a phone call or a lost lead.
- Lands on the homepageUnderstands the niche, but the headline repeats and two logos overlap.Hesitation
- Looks for a menu or contactThe menu button sits past the screen edge. Nothing to tap but “Learn more.”Failure
- Taps “Learn more about us”Lands on ecommercerecru.wpengine.com, a different web address.Hesitation
- Wants to send the roleFinds a call button 2.6 screens down. No email or form for an after-hours brief.Failure
A Director-level candidate, on a phone, wants open roles
Candidates become the shortlist, so their path matters too.
- Looks for “Jobs” in the menuCan’t open the menu on a phone.Failure
- Scrolls for a jobs link“View Jobs” is 5.2 screens down, at the very end.Hesitation
- Arrives on EcommerceJobs.comA different name and design, with no line saying it’s the same firm.Hesitation
- Browses roles10 listings (three closed or on hold), newest posted 2 weeks ago.Pass
A CMO on a laptop checks credibility before calling
The research visit, often after a referral or a LinkedIn message.
- Opens AboutFounder story, press and education are all there.Pass
- Scans the client list66 brands as small grey text with no logos or grouping.Hesitation
- Reads the teamTwo partners, each with a direct line. Whom should they call?Hesitation
- Clicks “Get in touch”Sent to EcommerceJobs.com’s contact form, through a double-slash link.Hesitation
Heuristic scores, one by one (0 = no issue, 4 = blocks the task)
| Heuristic | Score | What I saw |
|---|---|---|
| 1 · Visibility of system status | 2 | Buttons leave for other domains (staging, EcommerceJobs.com) without saying so. |
| 2 · Match with the real world | 1 | Testimonial carousels are headed “About Harry” and “About Allan,” which read like bios. |
| 3 · User control and freedom | 2 | Carousels auto-advance every 7 s; pausing works only on mouse hover. |
| 4 · Consistency and standards | 3 | Repeated headline, two logos, two names for one place (“Current Job Openings” and “View Jobs”). |
| 5 · Error prevention | 1 | A main link points at a staging server that could change or go away. |
| 6 · Recognition over recall | 3 | Phone menu can’t be seen or opened; contact options are hidden below the fold. |
| 7 · Flexibility and efficiency | 2 | One channel (a call) on the homepage; no way to send a brief. |
| 8 · Aesthetic and minimalist design | 2 | A 27-second background video and a ghost logo compete with the message; proof is buried. |
| 9 · Recovering from errors | 0 | No forms on the site, so nothing to fail. |
| 10 · Help and documentation | 2 | No “how it works” or fee explanation beyond the word “contingency.” Rivals show a process and FAQ. |
Heuristics total 18 of 40 (subscore 55). Task subscore 46 (12 steps: pass = 1, hesitation = ½, failure = 0). Manipulative design: none found (100). Weighted 50/35/15 → 59.
21 opportunities, ranked by what they cost in searches and trust
Must fix = costs inquiries or credibility today. Should fix = adds friction or leaves results on the table. Nice to have = polish.
| # | Priority | Where | What I found | Why it matters | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Must fix | Homepage hero | The headline renders “Ecommerce recruiting for B2C + B2B B2C + B2B ecommerce” on desktop and phone. The animated-headline module shows two copies of the same words, both set to “active.” | It’s the first sentence every visitor reads, and it reads like a typo, in the first sentence a hiring manager sees. | In the hero’s PowerPack “Animated Headline” module, give the rotating words two different values (“B2C” and “B2B”) or switch to a plain headline. |
| 2 | Must fix | Header, every page | The logo image and the site title text both display. On a 390-px phone, they push the menu button to x 390–432, past the screen edge. On scroll, the see-through sticky header lays both over the page text. | Phone visitors can’t reach About or Current Job Openings from the menu, and the overlap looks unfinished. | Astra Customizer → Site Identity: turn off “Display Site Title,” set a smaller mobile logo width, give the sticky header a solid background. |
| 3 | Must fix | Homepage hero | “Learn more about us” links to ecommercerecru.wpengine.com/about, a WP Engine staging address. The hero video (5.4 MB) also loads from that address. | Visitors leave the real domain on the main button. If the staging site changes or is removed, the button and video break. | Point the button to /about/. Upload the video (or a poster image) to the live media library and update the row. |
| 4 | Must fix | Homepage, About | The homepage offers one way in: “Give us a call at 404-281-2025,” 2.6 screens down on a phone. No email or form, and /contact/ returns “page not found.” About’s “Get in touch with us” goes to ecommercejobs.com//contact. Contact Form 7 is installed but unused. | Hiring managers often send a role by email or after hours. Each one who won’t call can be a search that never starts. | A short “Start a search” brief on this site (Contact Form 7 already exists), plus the phone and email in the header and first screen. |
| 5 | Must fix | Site-wide | MonsterInsights is installed, but the page source says “MonsterInsights is not currently configured… No tracking code set.” No other analytics run. | There’s no way to know how many people visit, where they come from, or whether a change brings more calls. | Connect MonsterInsights to a GA4 property, then count phone taps, form sends and clicks to EcommerceJobs.com as key events. |
| 6 | Must fix | About, homepage | The About page lists Allan Seibert as Partner (with the firm since 2010), with his own phone and email, and 11 of the 18 homepage testimonials sit under “About Allan.” | Two partners with two direct lines leave an employer unsure whom to call, and a team section that isn’t current raises doubts about the rest of the site. | Keep the team section to today’s lineup and the testimonials to the people a client will work with. |
| 7 | Should fix | Homepage | The homepage has no client list and no track-record numbers. About lists 66 brands, “hundreds” of closed searches and press from the WSJ to BusinessWeek, in small grey text. | Rivals lead with proof in the first screen (“Join 200+ companies,” “2,500+ organizations”). ECR has stronger proof and keeps it off the homepage. | A track record card in the hero and a client strip linking to the full list. |
| 8 | Should fix | Buttons and links | White on brand gold is 2.30:1 (including the “View Jobs” button); white on brand green is 2.41:1 (including the call button); green links on grey are 2.21:1. Lighthouse and axe both flag it. | Hard to read in sunlight and below the WCAG AA minimum of 4.5:1 (3:1 for large text). | Darken the green to #337534 (5.6:1 with white) and put dark text on gold (7.2:1). Same hues, readable. |
| 9 | Should fix | Homepage, phone | Lighthouse phone test: Performance 68, LCP 7.6 s. The hero’s background media is 848 KiB on phones (752 KiB could be saved), and 5.4 MB on desktop. No real-user data yet (too little traffic). | On a phone, the first screen fills in slowly, and the video adds little. | A compressed poster image (about 100 KB) on phones and a lighter video on desktop, hosted on the live site. |
| 10 | Should fix | Page code | 20 “Review” structured-data blocks with an empty “itemReviewed” name; Mike Mayer and Jared Lukin appear twice. | Invalid markup earns nothing, and Google doesn’t show review stars a business publishes about itself. Google | Turn off the testimonial plugin’s review markup; keep Organization data with name, logo, phone and sameAs. |
| 11 | Should fix | Every page | No og:image. The page asks for a large-image card but supplies no image. | Links shared in LinkedIn, Slack or email show no picture, which is how a recruiter’s link usually travels. | Yoast → Social: a 1200×630 default image with the name and a short promise. |
| 12 | Should fix | Both sites | EcommerceRecruiter.com links to EcommerceJobs.com three times on the homepage (two over http://). EcommerceJobs.com links back zero times, and its contact page is where employers end up. | The two sites split one firm’s reputation, and the jobs site links nothing back. | Give each site a job (see “Two sites, one firm”), link both ways, and use https. |
| 13 | Should fix | Sitemaps | Yoast’s sitemaps list 29 URLs. Only 3 are real pages; 18 are one-testimonial pages of about 200 words, 4 are testimonial-category pages and 4 are image attachment pages. | Thin pages crowd out the ones that should rank and look unfinished when they do show up. | Yoast: hide Testimonials from search and redirect attachment URLs. |
| 14 | Should fix | Homepage testimonials | Two carousels (7 and 11 quotes) advance every 7 seconds and pause only on mouse hover. Headings read “About Harry” and “About Allan.” | Most quotes are never seen, and moving content with no pause button misses WCAG 2.2.2. | Three strong quotes in full, a link to the rest, and no auto-advance. |
| 15 | Should fix | About | Practical Ecommerce interviewed Harry in December 2022 and January 2024, and both pieces link to this site. The site’s press list doesn’t include them. | Recent press shows a current, active expert; the listed outlets are older. | Add an “In the press” row with the recent interviews first. |
| 16 | Should fix | /blog/ | The Blog page, listed in the sitemap, is 184 characters: a link to Harry’s articles elsewhere and a comment box. Sitemap date: 2014. The feed has no posts. | A visitor who lands on it from search sees a page that looks unmaintained, from an expert who publishes elsewhere. | Turn it into “Insights,” listing Harry’s articles and interviews, or redirect it to About. |
| 17 | Nice to have | Homepage | Headings skip levels: H1, then H3, then H2; testimonials under H4. | Screen-reader users navigate by headings. | H1 → H2 per section → H3 inside. |
| 18 | Nice to have | About photos | Headshots of 465 KB and 1,024 KB (3840×5760) are shown about 345–510 px wide. Alt text is the file name (“DL3A2856”). | Slow on phones; screen readers announce a file name. | Resize to about 800 px WebP and describe the person. |
| 19 | Nice to have | Titles and copy | The homepage title is all caps and repeats “ECOMMERCE.” About repeats the homepage’s first paragraphs word for word. | Search results show the title as written; duplicate copy splits what each page is for. | “Ecommerce Recruiter · Contingency Executive Search, Manager to CXO.” Give About its own story. |
| 20 | Nice to have | Homepage | A leftover theme-demo image (websitedemos.net, pic28-free-img) returns 404 in the browser console. | Harmless to visitors; Lighthouse marks it under Best Practices. | Remove the reference from the template. |
| 21 | Nice to have | Server | No HSTS, Content-Security-Policy, X-Frame-Options or X-Content-Type-Options headers. | Basic hardening that WP Engine can switch on. | Ask WP Engine support to add standard security headers. |
Eight fixes, about an hour, all inside WordPress
No developer needed. Menu names can differ slightly by plugin version.
- Fix the headlineEdit the hero row → PowerPack
Animated Headline→ make the rotating words “B2C” and “B2B,” or switch to a plain headline.About 5 min · Finding 1 - One logo, a working phone menu
Appearance → Customize → Header → Site Identity: turn off “Display Site Title,” lower the mobile logo width.About 5 min · Finding 2 - Keep visitors on the real siteChange “Learn more about us” to
/about/; re-upload the hero video or a poster image.About 10 min · Finding 3 - Turn on measurement
Insights → Settings → Connect MonsterInsights, sign in to a GA4 property.About 10 min · Finding 5 - Update the teamEdit the About page’s team rows to today’s lineup.About 10 min · Finding 6
- Add a link-preview image
Yoast SEO → Settings → Social sharing: a 1200×630 default image.About 5 min · Finding 11 - Trim the index
Yoast SEO → Settings → Content types → Testimonials(and Testimonial categories): hide from search. Turn on attachment-URL redirects.About 5 min · Finding 13 - https everywhereChange the
http://ecommercejobs.commenu links and the body link tohttp://ecommercerecruiter.comto https.About 2 min · Finding 12
Step-by-step notes for whoever maintains the site: the fix sheet and concept specs.
Give each site one job, and link them both ways
EcommerceJobs.com holds the job listings and the email list: a Job of the Day email it says reaches 20,000 subscribers, a LinkedIn group it says has 112,005 members, open roles and a contact form. EcommerceRecruiter.com has the exact-match name, the client list, and the press links pointing at it.
EcommerceRecruiter.com
Best job: the employer site
- Track record, clients, testimonials
- “Start a search” brief and direct lines
- Press and founder story
(2 over http)
EcommerceJobs.com
Best job: the candidate site
- Open and filled roles, resume upload
- Job of the Day email, LinkedIn group
- A clear “Hiring? Start a search” link back
Today an employer who clicks “Get in touch” on About ends up on the jobs site’s contact form, and a candidate on the jobs site never learns about the firm’s client list. Labeled links both ways (“Hiring? See our track record” / “Looking? See open roles”) keep each visitor on the right path and let both sites share credit for the brand.
The stack is sound. Two tools are installed but idle.
Read from the page code, plugin folders and the WordPress API, November 16, 2026.
Same colors, readable at last
Lighthouse Accessibility 94 and a working focus ring are good starting points. The gaps are the brand’s button colors, checked with Lighthouse and axe-core.
Today: white on #60BA622.41:1 · below AA
Concept: white on #3375345.62:1 · passes AA
Today: white on #D9A13B2.30:1 · below AA
Concept: #1F1F1F on #D9A13B7.15:1 · passes AAA
| Lighthouse, Nov 16, 2026 | Performance | Accessibility | Best practices | SEO | Largest paint |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Homepage · phone | 68 | 94 | 96 | 100 | 7.6 s |
| Homepage · desktop | 91 | 94 | 96 | 100 | 1.5 s |
Real-user (Core Web Vitals) data: none yet; Google needs more visits to report it. Lab numbers are from PageSpeed Insights.
Three ecommerce recruiters, side by side
Talentfoot, eCommerce Placement and ACCUR, checked on November 16, 2026. All three put a promise and a next step in the first phone screen; Talentfoot and eCommerce Placement lead with a proof number.




| EcommerceRecruiter | Talentfoot | eCommerce Placement | ACCUR | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hiring / job-seeker doors up top | No (“Learn more”) | Hire Today · Find A Job | Hire Today · Find a Job | Contact Us · Learn More |
| Phone in the header | No | Yes | No | Yes (top bar) |
| Proof in the first screen | None | “Join 2,500+ organizations” | “Join 200+ companies” | Specialty list |
| Clients on the homepage | Only in testimonial titles | Logo strip | Logo strip, success story | Testimonials, Forbes list |
| Something to download or read | Blog page is empty | Blog, Knowledge Center | 2026 salary guide | Newsroom |
| Lighthouse, phone (perf · SEO) | 68 · 100 | 49 · 92 | 100 · 100 | 73 · 92 |
| Real-user speed (Core Web Vitals) | Not enough data | Passed | Passed | Passed |
0 proofECR shows no proof in its first phone screen, yet it has the deepest proof of the group: hundreds of searches since 2005 and 66 named brands. Moving it up is the cheapest win in the set.
What to do, in order
Measure first, so every later change can be judged against a baseline.
This week
- The eight WordPress fixes above (Findings 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 11, 12, 13)
- GA4 key events: phone taps, emails, clicks to EcommerceJobs.com
- Confirm Search Console and submit the sitemap
Next 30 days
- Track record card and client strip on the homepage (7)
- “Start a search” brief with Contact Form 7 (4)
- Accessible button colors (8); poster image instead of video on phones (9)
- Fix review markup, press row, Insights page (10, 15, 16)
Days 30–90
- Homepage rebuilt to the concept, with three quotes in full (14)
- Two-way links with EcommerceJobs.com (12)
- A yearly ecommerce leadership pay snapshot from Harry’s searches, as the site’s lead magnet (eCommerce Placement offers one)
- Monthly report: visits, sources, calls, briefs
One extra search a quarter pays for all of this
Change the inputs to your own numbers. The defaults are examples, not EcommerceRecruiter.com data. The calculator sizes the prize; measurement decides what stays.
Every fix is a hypothesis until the numbers agree
A site with modest traffic can’t run a quick A/B test on everything, so the plan matches the method to the traffic.
- Measure firstGA4 with phone taps, briefs and jobs clicks as key events. Four weeks of baseline.
- Write the hypothesis“Proof in the first screen raises brief starts,” with the finding it comes from.
- Pick the test that fitsA/B where traffic allows; before/after periods with call tracking where it doesn’t.
- Set the bar in advancePrimary metric, guardrails and length decided before launch. No peeking.
- Keep what winsShip the winner, log the result, move to the next hypothesis.
| Test | Change | Primary metric | Guardrail | Ships only if | Method |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| First screen | Concept hero vs. today | Brief starts + phone taps per employer visit | Bounce rate | Contacts per visit rise and bounce doesn’t | Before/after, 4 weeks each |
| Proof | Track record card vs. none | Clicks to Start a search | Time to first tap | Starts rise with no slower first tap | A/B if 300+ visits a week |
| Brief form | Short (4 fields) vs. full brief | Completed briefs | Share of briefs with a role and pay range | More briefs and quality holds | A/B on the Start page |
How long would a test take?
My process
I opened every page on a laptop and in a 390-pixel phone frame, measured where each button sits, and walked three tasks as an employer, a candidate and a researcher. I ran Lighthouse through PageSpeed Insights and axe-core in the browser, then checked every automated flag by eye and dropped the ones caused by my own browser extensions. I read the page code, sitemaps, robots file and WordPress API to see what’s installed and what’s switched on. I compared first screens with three rivals on the same day, scored the site against Nielsen’s ten heuristics, and built the concept in the brand’s own green, gold and Poppins, darkened only where contrast required it. I didn’t submit any form, accept cookies, or contact anyone.
Not covered: screen-reader testing, 200% zoom, the site’s admin, Search Console data and real traffic, which only the owner can see.